We recommend offering fresh Nyjer® (thistle) because it is goldfinches’ favorite feeder food. And since the female goldfinch typically chooses her mate--rather than vice versa--she doesn't need to be brilliant yellow to attract the male's attention. To attract goldfinches to your yard, we recommend offering the right food and designated finch feeders or a designated finch-feeding station. Recommended Food. Goldfinches will actually come to your feeders in much larger numbers in the fall and winter in search of food so its a great time to get large flocks of them! Recommended Food One reason for this is nesting behavior; winter-flocking goldfinches break up into breeding pairs and stay close to their nesting sites. Goldfinches are found in most habitats across North America, including backyards. Another reason is the seasonal abundance of natural foods as goldfinches feed first on new growth and flower buds, and then on the … Habitat. CAVEAT: Although breeding females ARE much drabber than males, their summer plumage typically does have more yellow than what they wear in winter… Yellow finches, also known as American goldfinches, are often sought after by birdwatchers because of their bright plumage. In her upstate New York yard, photographer Marie Read tends a native plant garden that’s just for the birds. They are here in our area in the winter and early spring. To attract goldfinches to your yard, we recommend offering the right food and designated finch feeders or a designated finch-feeding station. These small birds are native to North America and appear most often in the winter as they migrate south. Goldfinches are found in most habitats across North America, including backyards. A lot of people just assume they are sparrows. How to Attract Goldfinches. How to Attract Goldfinches to Your Garden To identify a few other plant options, I talked with people who spend a lot of time watching birds—wildlife photographers. The finches actually lose their bright yellow color in the winter and turn a nice shade of olive brown.